Skip to main content

To: John Morea, CEO: Scotia Gas Networks Ltd.; Southern Gas Networks plc; SGN Commercial Services Ltd.; SGN Connections Ltd. and SGN Contracting Ltd.

Why is Scotia Gas, a national gas distributor, supporting the unauthorised Crouchland Biogas plant?

SGN (Scotia Gas Networks) are petitioned to stop supporting the unauthorised Crouchland Biogas Ltd. industrial gas plant by removing all SGN owned equipment installed and being used without appropriate planning permissions at the Crouchland Biogas site located at Crouchland Farm, Rickmans Lane, Plaistow, West Sussex.

Why is this important?

Why is a national gas distributor, continuing to partner with an unlawful industrial gas plant? Why does SSE, a national energy firm who own 50% of SGN, condone this? The Timeline:
• 27May16: Crouchland seeks adjournment to EA case. Worthing Magistrates Court agrees to 24 June.
• 17May16: Traffic Inquiry reconvenes. Decision pending.
• 11-12May: Appeal against Cert. of Lawfulness is heard. Decision pending.
• 29Apr: The EA announce legal proceedings against Crouchland Farms Ltd in relation to Dec 2013 pollution of the River Kird. Crouchland Farms Ltd and Crouchland Biogas are linked; Leon Mekitarian is Director of both and Angus Cameron resigned directorship of Crouchland Farms in 2013. No announcements yet on 2015 / 2016 significant pollution incidents.• 29Mar: P.O.R.E receives a letter stating “The Gas Alliance Group (including Gas Bus Alliance) no longer take any Biomethane from Crouchland Farms Ltd or Crouchland Biogas Ltd.” and threatening legal action should villagers “communicate any information ... contrary to this statement”. The signatory is Tony Griffiths, former General Manager of MAN UK bus operations.
• 29 Mar: Barry Evans resigns from Crouchland Biogas.
• 16Mar: Another significant pollution incident occurs and while a cleanup in progress, SGN disassociate themselves stating Crouchland is separate and they have no corporate responsibility for the actions of this ‘autonomous’ company. All contrary to CEO John Morea’s 2013 Annual Report to shareholders, that Crouchland was SGN's partner; and from an email to WSCC 28Aug2014 supporting the retrospective planning application, stating "Our pioneering partnership with Crouchland Biogas..." And even though SGN have a fixed and floating charge on the property and undertakings of Crouchland Biogas Ltd, a company that has had multiple breaches of their EA Permit, has caused significant and serious pollution events, is operating without planning permission and is the subject of an ongoing Traffic Commissioners Public Inquiry.
• 4Mar: Crouchland Biogas apply to the EA to vary an environmental permit involving substantial change (EPR/CB3208XJ/V002).
• 12Jan2016: Farm Fuel Ltd called to a Traffic Commissioner enquiry for breaches to their Operator’s licence, effectively using the farm as an unauthorised Operating Centre.
• Nov2015: Plaistow & Ifold and Kirdford Parish Councils –with- The Plaistow Village Trust and P.O.R.E unite in opposition to launch a planning fund for expert / legal representation at the 4 Appeals.
• Oct: Crouchland lodge appeals with the Planning Inspectorate against the Enforcement Notices (to dismantle all equipment installed without planning permission and to stop operating as a commercial biogas plant); retrospective planning refusal and the Cert. of Lawfulness.
• 1Sep: WSCC issue a Certificate of Lawfulness EXCLUDING the conditioning and export of gas, importation of waste and any other materials for anaerobic digestion and many items of development.
• 16Jul: CDC issue 2 Enforcement Notices with staggered compliance dates for cease of use of the land and 6 months for the remaining requirements (PS/13/00015/CONCOU).
• 23Jun: The Environment Agency attends a pollution incident to 1km of an adjoining farm’s watercourse which has significant impact on the ecology and the ability to water livestock.
• 16Jun: CDC inform WSCC they strongly object to granting a Certificate of Lawfulness.
• 2Jun: WSCC pass CDC responsibility to investigate and serve Enforcement but are clear that multiple breaches of planning have occurred.
• 26May: Crouchland apply for a Certificate of Lawfulness for the proposed use as an AD facility with UNRESTRICTED throughput of imported waste or other material and the export of gas and digestate (WSCC/036/15/PS).
• 7Apr: WSCC issue a Decision Notice REFUSING retrospective planning.
• 4Mar-To Date: Despite planning refused, expansion continues. Ofgem confirm SGN Commercial Services owns equipment enabling gas conditioning and exportation in 'Farm Fuel' HGVs to SGN’s Portsdown Hill, Portsmouth injection facility.
• 3Mar: WSCC planning committee REFUSE the retrospective application on multiple grounds.
• WSCC receive 431+ objection letters (including from 7 Parish Councils / CPRE) and 1050+ people sign a petition, requesting refusal of retrospective planning.
• Unauthorised commercial operations continue with extremely high numbers of HGV and other traffic movements through Parishes.
• Oct2014: Inexplicably, WSCC Planning Officers withdraw enforcement notices leaving communities exposed to continued, excessive and inappropriate activity and HGV movements.
• 4Jul: Crouchland submit a retrospective planning application (WSCC/042/14/PS).
• May: The respected Crouchland Farm Manager (former NFU Deputy) resigns.
• Apr: WSCC serve 2 Enforcement Notices (against the erection of unauthorised anaerobic digestion equipment and the change from an operation ancillary to a farm use, to a waste use) requiring the illegal commercial activity to cease.
• Mar2014: After years of complaint of the expansion by stealth and material-change-of-use from an agricultural, farm-related operation into a waste development WSCC serve a Planning Contravention Notice.
• Mar2013: SGN sign a 20year contract BEFORE Crouchland obtain planning permission.
• 1Jan-Jun2013: Professional investors join as directors and/or shareholders: Barry Evans and Ewen ‘Angus’ Cameron (a cousin of PM David Cameron).
• 2012: Plaistow & Ifold Parish Council notify CDC of development/engineering works being undertaken without planning.
• 16Nov11: Leon Mekitarian appointed Managing Director.
• 20Apr11: Crouchland Biogas Ltd. incorporation - William Luttman-Johnson (registered owner of Crouchland Farm) as Managing Director.
• 2007-2008: Crouchland dairy farm with 750 Holstein Friesians, obtains planning consent (with local support) from CDC for an On-Farm AD unit to produce electricity to grid.

How it will be delivered

An email will be sent to Scotia Gas CEO and a Press Release issued.

United Kingdom

Maps © Stamen; Data © OSM and contributors, ODbL

Links

Updates

2015-10-16 16:02:58 +0100

Crouchland Biogas have appealed the Chichester District Council 2 enforcement notices. It’s important people write to the Planning Inspectorate by the 23rd October 2015 and state your objection. You MUST send 3 COPIES of your written letter -AND- quote each of the following 3 reference numbers on each page of your letter:
APP/L3815/C/15/3133236
APP/L3815/C/15/3133237
Chichester District Council Case Number: PS/13/00015/CONCOU

Address: Mr Ben White, The Planning Inspectorate, 3/23 Temple Quay House, 2 The Square, Temple Quay, Bristol, BS1 6PN
Alternatively Email, but remember, quote all 3 reference numbers: [email protected]

2015-10-09 15:17:46 +0100

Crouchland Biogas have Appealed 2 enforcement notices issued by Chichester District Council. We OBJECT to the unauthorised development of the site, from an on-farm Anaerobic Digestion facility to generate electricity; to an industrial-scale operation producing gas and digestate exported by tanker, with huge importations of waste and other material. If granted consent HGV movements will be year-in/year-out and give Crouchland potential to expand further. Even if you’ve already written to WSCC or to CDC, please write now to the Planning Inspectorate by the 23rd October 2015: Mr Ben White, The Planning Inspectorate, 3/23 Temple Quay House, 2 The Square, Temple Quay, Bristol, BS1 6PN OR Email The Planning Inspectorate [email protected] You must send 3 copies of your letter and on each page quote: the Planning Inspectorate Reference Ros. APP/L3815/C/15/3133236 –&– APP/L3815/C/15/3133237 –&– CDC Case No: PS/13/00015/CONCOU

2015-08-03 12:56:58 +0100

https://www.facebook.com/poreorg/posts/1621989671374305

2015-08-03 12:56:48 +0100

Update from the Environment Agency Solent & South Downs Area on 23 June incident at Crouchland Farm: EA staff continue to focus on ensuring Crouchland Biogas completes cleaning up the liquid waste pollution which is almost complete. The dam at the lowest end of the affected stream prevents polluted water moving further downstream. The operator’s contractor is monitoring water quality and won't remove the dam until it's certain it won’t cause further pollution downstream. There are still small pockets of pollution upstream of the dam for clean up. We've investigated a new report of 26 July of further potential pollution and concluded it was caused by existing stream pollution being washed downstream by heavy rainfall. The impact was minor as the polluted water was intercepted by the dam at the lowest end of the affected stream. Our investigation continues and details will be limited until all facts are completely understood. Report pollution incidents to the 24 hour hotline 0800 807060.

2015-07-26 16:06:34 +0100

The Rt Hon Amber Rudd (Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change) has responded she agrees with Andrew Tyrie MP, that the case for suspension of funding of the Crouchland operations through the Ofgem ROCs scheme, would appear to be overwhelming.

2015-07-25 09:10:42 +0100

Andrew Tyrie MP has asked a letter he has sent to the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change (Rt Hon Amber Rudd MP) be shared amongst those following the Crouchland BioGas saga.
He discusses the subsidies Crouchland BioGas is receiving through the Government's (in this case Ofgem) Renewable Obligations Certificates (ROCs) scheme. He notes that one of the preliminary accreditation requirements of the scheme is that the necessary consents, including planning permission have been obtained.
Crouchland BioGas Ltd. is non-compliant with the ROC scheme policy in its expanded AD unit and the exportation of biogas. This month Chichester District Council issued 2 enforcement notices to Crouchland BioGas Ltd., this follows the March 2015 refusal of their retrospective planning application by West Sussex County Council.
http://www.pore.org.uk/news/2015/7/24/andrew-tyrie-mp-writes-to-the-secretary-of-state-for-energy-and-climate-change

2015-07-20 18:33:19 +0100

Chichester District Council has issued two separate planning enforcement notices to Crouchland BioGas Ltd. which come into effect on the 26th August 2015 (unless an appeal is made against it beforehand) with staggered compliance dates of 1 month for cease of use of the land and 6 months for the remaining requirements. Should the notices be appealed, enforcement action will be held in abeyance until the appeal is determined.

2015-07-02 11:34:07 +0100

https://www.facebook.com/poreorg/posts/1612451785661427
Crouchland BioGas 'Farm Fuel' HGV after HGV through Loxwood and down towards Pulborough Wednesday 1st July 2015.

2015-07-02 11:32:48 +0100

Andrew Tyrie MP has confirmed Wednesday 1 July 2015, that he will be writing directly to the Secretary of State, regarding Crouchland BioGas - and will forward his reply to the many residents who have written to him, regarding this company.

2015-06-29 19:44:04 +0100

https://www.facebook.com/poreorg/posts/1610479045858701:0
Update from the Environment Agency regarding a discharge of liquid waste from Crouchland Farm:
''Polluting matter did enter a local watercourse but this has now been contained. Sadly, the polluting matter has had a significant impact along 1km of the watercourse, both on the ecology and on its ability to support livestock watering. We do not consider there to be any further risk to the environment but the polluting material needs to be cleared up.

We are actively involved in monitoring the operator’s clean up and making sure that it is carried out effectively. Our incident command unit has gone from the site but a site controller will visit each day to check on progress.

A full investigation is ongoing so further details will be limited until all the facts of the case are completely understood.......
We would continue to urge anyone to report incidents of pollution to our 24 hour hotline on 0800 807060.''

2015-06-25 13:16:41 +0100

On the 23rd June 2015 a pollution incident occurred originating from the Crouchland BioGas AD plant and the Environment Agency incident team are still in attendance. This is the second such event in several weeks, though this recent case has much more serious implications. A dam has been constructed to stop the digestate spreading. Aquatic life has been killed in a one mile section. A nearby farmer has relocated livestock from 50 acres of his fields. The polluted waterways will need to be delved out completely. Follow the story on the P.O.R.E. facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/poreorg/posts/1609483122624960" data-width="500"

2015-06-25 13:13:45 +0100

Chichester District Council – Planning Committee today (24th June) voted in the majority for enforcement action at Crouchland BioGas and the issue of two enforcement notices under s172 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended by the Planning Compensation Act 1995).

Speaking ‘whole-heartedly supporting the recommendation for the enforcement’ action were Plaistow & Ifold Parish Council Chairman (Sara Burrell), Kirdford Parish Chairman (Ian Campbell) and a representative from the community action group P.O.R.E. (Clarissa Bushell).

Speaking against enforcement action and on behalf of Crouchland BioGas was Managing Director, Leon Mekitarian. His speech was full of warnings to embroil CDC in legal action should the members vote in favour of enforcement.

2015-06-23 08:11:05 +0100

Please show support for the continuing and growing objections to Crouchland BioGas Ltd. at the next Chichester District Council Planning Meeting.
Date: Wednesday, 24th June 2015
Time: 09.30am
Address: Committee Rooms, East Pallant House, 1 East Pallant, Chichester, PO19 1TY
Agenda Item 15: Crouchland BioGas Ltd.
Chichester District Council Enforcement Manager in her report to the CDC planning committee has recommended formal Enforcement action and the issuance of 2 Enforcement notices.

2015-06-19 13:59:58 +0100

16 June 2015: The Head of Planning Services (CDC), in a letter to WSCC, states the District Council strongly object to the granting of a certificate of lawfulness for the [Crouchland BioGas] development and consider that planning permission is required for the proposed use. Planning permission is also required for the associated operational development that remains unauthorised on site. https://publicaccess.chichester.gov.uk/online-applications/applicationDetails.do?activeTab=documents&keyVal=NOYNBPER0UU00

2015-06-19 08:46:49 +0100

Show support for the continuing and growing objections to Crouchland BioGas Ltd. at the next Chichester District Council Planning Meeting.
Date: Wednesday, 24th June 2015
Time: 09.30am
Address: Committee Rooms, East Pallant House, 1 East Pallant, Chichester, PO19 1TY

Agenda Item: Crouchland BioGas Enforcement: The CDC Enforcement Manager has issued a report for the CDC planning committee where formal Enforcement action and the issuance of 2 Enforcement notices are recommended (document reference: http://chichester.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s2438/15.0%20Crouchland%20Farm%20Rickmans%20Lane%20Kirdford.pdf).